When Canada Reads starts up it seems to be over just as quickly. With that in mind I try to savor every minute of the debates. Today, again, I feel that we have a wonderful group of people on the panel and I really like Nicolas Campbell’s strategy.
In day two there seemed to be a lot of discussion about Fruit. Now I don’t have a problem with that but most of the discussion seemed negative. Now Campbell and some others on the panel don’t think Fruit is a book they couldn’t recommend to everyone. This would be a down side to the book, but I think that the Canada Reads 2009 pick should be something that challenges readers in someway, which I think Fruit does. The concept of talking nipples is fantastic and it’s the most memorable part of the novel so I’m not really sure why Jen Sookfong Lee thinks she needs to mention that all the time.
Nicolas Campbell has a wonderful strategy. His strategy, and he’s said it himself, is to draw the panelists attention away from his book (The Outlander). I guess that’s because if you don’t talk about it the negatives cannot come out. But I’m alright with that, from what I’ve heard about the book I’m really excited to read it now.
The first blow came at the expense of David Adams Richards’ Mercy Among the Children. This seems to be getting quite a bit of negative press on Canada Reads, almost as much as Fruit. It has been getting so much negative feedback that I’m not really looking forward to the book, it’s getting to the point where it’s looking like reading it will be a daunting task. I’ll try not to let that bother me when I get to it
So, where does this take us on the Canada Reads 2009 journey? Well, the panelists voted for the first book out. We aren’t going to find out exactly what that book is until the beginning of tomorrows instalment. I’m afraid that the first book out will be Fruit by Brian Francis but I hope it’s not. I really think the panelists need to see the book for what it is and appreciate the quirky qualities it possesses. It also seems that The Fat Woman Next Door is Pregnant by Michel Tremblay is leading the pack, which is great. The characters are wonderful, and I don’t think Tremblay could write a bad character if he wanted even the worst person he’d write about would have some kind of endearing quality.
It’ll be interesting to see where the panelists take us tomorrow.
4 thoughts on “Canada Reads – Day 2”
I hope it’s not Mercy that goes, it was a good book and I would still recommend it. Don’t be put of by those comments!
My mom is trying to read all the books, and she didn’t enjoy Fruit very much, but she didn’t even finish the Fat Woman Next Door.
I’m liking these updates.
raidergirl3: I’m trying not to be put off by these comments, I’m still going to read it so I hope I enjoy more than the panelists do.
I really enjoyed Fruit but I’m having some difficulty with The Fat Woman Next Door is Pregnant but I love Michel Tremblay’s work for the stage and for that reason I root for him.
I’m glad you enjoy the updates, it’s good to know somebody enjoys what you do.
But if it’s Canada Reads, they can’t pick a book that isn’t good to read even though his other books are good. That one has to go then.
raidergirl3: I know, I guess I should just be happy that he’s getting the attention he deserves through this competition.